OHSAA to vote on public and private school tournament separation

ZANESVILLE, OH – As announced by the Ohio High School Athletic Association (OHSAA) on Wednesday afternoon, it will conduct a vote next May to decide on separating public and private schools into separate postseason tournament divisions. This comes after receiving a completed petition to force a referendum vote next year.
Entering the 2026-2027 academic school year, 813 schools are OHSAA member schools, 691 of which (approximately 85%) are public while 121 of which (15%) are not. Per the governing body’s bylaws, each high school principal will cast one vote, and a majority will pace this proposition. This isn’t the first time that this will come to a vote, having previously been presented unsuccessfully in 1978 and most recently in 1993.
“Our constitution permits the petition process and now we’ll meet with our membership to walk through this proposal, present facts, and explain what separate tournaments would mean” says Doug Ute, the OHSAA Executive Director. “We believe that separate tournaments would have some negative unintended consequences. The OHSAA is a reflection of our membership and we will create a forum to discuss and consider both perspectives.”
If passed, Ohio would become the ninth state to separate tournaments, and take effect beginning in the 2028-29 school year.
This decision does not come lightly though, not only affecting the postseason division breakdowns, but also effectively eliminating the competitive balance process. The process helps sort divisions for soccer, volleyball, football, basketball, softball, and baseball each year beginning in 2017.
“Competitive balance has an impact in those sports, and we continue to study that process to see if there is more that can be done” says Ute, who has served in his Executive Director role since 2020.
He adds, that some “misconceptions” with private schools need to be addressed when talking about the impact of this proposed separation.
From 2001 through the 2017 school years, public schools won 56% of state championships in competitive balance sports, while private schools won 44%, per OHSAA data. In the nine and a half years since the competitive balance proposal went into effect, that number has shifted to 66% and 34% respectively.
Of the 27 local area OHSAA member schools, only three of which are private: Granville Christian Academy, Newark Catholic, and Bishop Rosecrans.
A decision on the matter will come during the annual referendum voting period from May 1st to the 15th in 2027.
